critical examination of the article:``progressive development of international environmental law and state responsibility''

recently we faced with a scientific journal, named ``journal of environmental & technology''. although the most content of this journal had scientific and technical aspect relating to environment, the subject of the last article in this issue (no. 26, 1384) was on international environmental law. off course the tittle of the article which was ``progressive development of international environmental law and state responsibility'', usually attracts some lawyers to read it. during studing of the said article, we understood, how basic prolems existes, procedural and substantive, in this article. this matter caused that we started to critically review it. it is worthy to note that, we do not know the author of the article, but for the sake of supporting the high position of knowledge and scientists as well as giving value to the valuable books and articles, we decided to analyseit critically without any personal benefit. we hope the present article causes stopping the countinuation of the issue of these kind of papers in scientific journals.